Halloween Pencil Toppers


Get FREE SHIPPING on all orders over $35!!

 Items are made to order, processing times are from 3-5 business days.

 Need this sooner? Please contact me before ordering.


These are perfect for anyone who uses a pen or pencil and wants to show off their personality and style. These make great gifts as well. Pencil toppers are perfect for classroom treat bags and party favor bags.


Copyright is owned by Baby WhatKnots LLC 2010-Current.


#2 pencil
felt applique

Packaging and Delivery:

Pencil toppers and pencils arrive displayed on professionally printed product cards and are wrapped in tissue paper with a coordinating ribbon and tag. These arrive beautifully for yourself or, if you are giving this as a gift it will be all ready for that special person.

The Little Details:

**Please remember each item is handmade so it is possible for some slight variation.

Cleaning Instructions:
Hand wash only and let air dry.

CAUTION/ATTENTION: Buyer assumes full responsibility of using this item.

Hello!  My name is Melissa and I am a stay at home Mom to three wonderful children. I started my Baby WhatKnots business in 2010 and I truly enjoy what I do.  God has blessed me with an amazing husband and three wonderful  children. I would love to share with you how I started my business and how God has led me right where I need to be. 

A Blessing in Disguise

In 2009, during the economic downturn, I was laid off from my job. At the time, my husband and I were expecting our first child and I was 8 months pregnant. The plan had always been for me to be a working mom; day care, car pool, the whole thing. After I lost my job, I quickly scrambled to return things back to normal. I remember taking my big old belly on several interviews and never receiving a call back.

My daughter was born several weeks later and it didn't take long for me to realize that I wanted to stay home with her. I just couldn’t imagine having to go back to work. After she was born, I started to make her accessories. It started with burp cloths and blankets and then moved on to pacifier clips and hair bows. It was something that I enjoyed doing and it wasn’t long before I had friends and family requesting items from me.

In 2010 I opened my first online store and started selling my creations. Several years ago, I came across the concept of the Jesse Tree. I started to make and sell sets in my shop and local community and my business has now grown to selling hundreds of sets a year. I am so grateful that God has blessed me in so many ways and given me this opportunity to spread the Gospel.

I look back now and know that God had a plan for me all along. I felt so scared and defeated the day that I lost my job. I was so confused about what God was doing but I’ve learned now that even when things don't make sense, I need to trust Him. 

"For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the Lord, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future." Jeremiah 29:11

Processing Time

Each of our items are handmade to order.  Please allow 3-5 business days for processing

Returns and Exchanges

I gladly accept returns, exchanges, and cancellations

Contact me within: 7 days of delivery
Ship items back within: 14 days of delivery
Request a cancellation within: 2 days of purchase

The following items can't be returned or exchanged

Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:

  • Custom or personalized orders
Returns and exchange details

If you need to return your order for any reason, simply contact us within 7 days of the delivery date. Once received back, orders will receive a full merchandise refund with the exception of Jesse Tree ornaments sets and the wooden display trees ** Jesse Tree ornament sets and our wooden display trees purchased after December 15th, will have a 10% restock fee that will not be refunded ** Buyer is responsible for return shipping. Return shipping must include a tracking number so that we can ensure it comes pack and refund you promptly. Unfortunately, custom items cannot be returned. If you have any questions, please send us a message.


We accept payments via Paypal


USPS First Class Mail service is 3-5 days (excludes Sunday)
USPS Priority Mail service is 1-4 days (excludes Sunday)
USPS Priority Express Mail service is an overnight shipping service

*** Please note that Priority Mail Express is the only guaranteed service. The Post Office sometimes runs behind, please consider upgrading to this service if purchasing close to Christmas or other major holidays***

Delivery times are provided by the United States Postal Service, however, occasionally packages can be delayed. If you have a specific "need by" date, we highly recommend that you purchase the Priority Express Mail Service, as this is the only guaranteed service.

Our shipping does not include insurance but it can be purchased upon request.

Please verify that your address is correct prior to checkout. We will ship your order to the address provided.

Once your order has shipped, a tracking number will be sent to you. We regular monitor the tracking to ensure the package is delivered. If for some reason your package becomes lost or damaged, you will be offered a full refund or a replacement at no additional charge.


Q: What is our current processing time?
A: Each of our items are handmade to order.  Please allow 3-5 business days for processing

Q: Do we offer free shipping?
A: We currently offer free domestic shipping on orders of $35 or more.

Q: Do we have any coupon codes?
A: Yes, we do offer coupon codes several times throughout the year. Coupons are good on regular priced items only. Coupons must be entered at the time of the order. One coupon may be used per order. Coupons are not valid on wholesale or custom orders. Please visit us on Facebook or Instagram for our latest deals and promotions.

Q: What are our business hours? When can we be reached?
A: Our standard business hours are Monday - Friday from 6:00 am CST until 4:00 pm CST. If you contact us, we usually will respond with 48 hours.  Please see our Shop Announcement section for updates regarding changes to our normal hours as they do vary occasionally especially around major holidays.

Q: Do we accommodate custom orders?
A: Yes, we do take custom orders. Please note, custom items cannot be returned. Please contact us so we may discuss the details.

Q: Do we offer wholesale pricing?
A: Yes, we do offer wholesale pricing. Please contact us so we may assist you.

Q: Do we offer a RUSH order option?
A: Yes, we are usually able to accommodate a RUSH order. RUSH orders do have an additional fee. Please contact us so we may assist you.

Q: Do we except returns?
A: If you need to return your order for any reason, simply contact us within 7 days of receiving your order for a full merchandise refund. Buyer is responsible for return shipping. Unfortunately, custom items cannot be returned. If you have any questions, you can reach us here in our shop.