Menu
All Things Witchy Maker Challenge Collection
All Things Witchy Maker Challenge Collection


Winner - Paula McNulty Designs
Finalist - Northern Owl Creations


Top Submissions

Free Shipping
The Lydia, Smoky Quartz Crystal Crown
Judy&Madeleine
Austin, TX
$75.00
Free Shipping
2"x6" Gold Orange Coffin Bookmark with Tassel - Halloween Car...
Cafe de Mynx
Louisville, KY
$3.99
Halloween purse with witches, black cats and ravens
Simply Nifty Bags
Fuquay Varina, NC
$49.95
Crescent moon and star coin brass witchy boho statement earrings
Love Laurel Rae
Buckeye, AZ
$28.00

More to Consider

Free Shipping
Window Cling Suncatcher Halloween Cat
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$6.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Rainbow Moonstone 14k Gold Filled Ring • Faceted Crescent Moo...
Jackrabbit Crystals
Roseville, CA
$26.00
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
BAT Small Coffin Wallet
Morrow & Meowley
PHILADELPHIA, PA
$49.95
Free Shipping
Cat Book Earrings
Goose Girl
King George, VA
$14.95
Goddess Altar
Crescent Auras, LLC
Vineyard, UT
$55.00
Activated charcoal soap scented with blend of patchouli, sand...
ikkilikki
Wilmington, NC
$8.95
Black leather masquerade mask for unisex adult. Wicked witch,...
Beadmask
Olympia, WA
$54.00
Cosmic Witch 6.5oz Candle, Ozone Jasmine Musk
Serpent & Flame Candle Co
Alsip, IL
$15.99
Free Shipping
Colorful Witch Brooms for Adults, Teens, Tweens and Child, Un...
Meckley Brooms
Lebanon, PA
$80.00
Free Shipping
Real Leather Witch Cauldron Pouch, 5' x 7" Tarot Pouch, Orac...
Triple Goddess Craft
Clayton, NC
$13.00
Crochet Witch Hat: Abigale
Black Water Crafts
Southaven, MS
$45.00
Free Shipping
Necklace set | Elemental magic, Tektite pendants, collar styl...
Dark Poet Designs | Unique Bead Jewelry
Los Ranchos, NM
$179.00
Free Shipping
Black witch cat for Halloween decor
Gypsy wagon on five acres
Laurens, SC
$40.00
Free Shipping
Enchanted Hauntscape Window Cling
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Pumpkin and Star Freehand Embroidered Pillow Halloween Decor
Yelli Kelli
AL
$42.00
Free Shipping
Midnight Bats Beanie
Pixelknit
Idyllwild, CA
$32.00
Halloween Bracelet Stack for WomenMen-Kids
Starfish by Kristan
Delray Beach, FL
$12.95
Blood and Bone Scarlet Pearl Necklace
The Mystic Victorian
Aubrey, TX
$90.00
Free Shipping
Custom cuddle dragon with hoodie
Rivermist Creations
Stillwater, OK
$138.00
Free Shipping
Halloween Decoration: mini woven wall hanging with silver "Book of Spells" charm locket. Plaid pattern in yellow gold, teal green, red violet, mauve purple. Top half view.
Free Shipping
Halloween Decor Handwoven Wall Hanging with Book of Spells Si...
Can Do Girl Design
San Diego, CA
$39.95
Free Shipping
Black poop bag holder with RIP Coffin shape. Personalization ...
A Fur Baby Favorite
CENTRE, AL
$19.95
- 17%
Skull Planchette Pendant, Hand Polished (Halloween Talking Sp...
Mechanical Whispers
NY
$74.99 $89.99
Witchy Oops
Country Treasures
Monticello, KY
$7.95
Illustrated mini journals - Teacup Garden (set of 3)
The Paper Cauldron
GA
$34.95
Witch Kitty Plush Animal Set
Creations by Orange
Goodyear, AZ
$30.00
Amethyst Lamp
Hillside Designs AZ
Phoenix, AZ
$250.00
Free Shipping
Witch bells door hanger
All The Things
Pasadena, MD
$12.00
Free Shipping
Cute Cauldron Earrings
Goose Girl
King George, VA
$14.95
Skeleton Hands I Love You, Iron-on Embroidered Patch
The Copper Addict's Attic
Grasston, MN
$10.00
Dear Salem You Missed One Witch Journal Unique Leatherette Co...
Barker Markings
CA
$27.99
Free Shipping
Halloween Paint and Play Set
Northern Owl Creations
Lehi, UT
$38.00
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Halloween Haunted Doll Candy Coffin Upcycled
Susan's Sweet Finds
Gilbert, AZ
$135.00
Free Shipping
Witchy Enamel Camp Mug 1692 They Missed One Witch Cup
Life in Color Design
CA
$16.99
- 15%
Skull Witch Pentagram Pendant, Hand Polished (Halloween Penta...
Mechanical Whispers
NY
$84.99 $99.99
Hauntingly Beautiful Halloween Candy Corn Beaded Charm Necklace
Starfish by Kristan
Delray Beach, FL
$19.95
Gemstone dangle hoop earrings, with amethyst slices, yellow quartz, and labradorite.
Gemstone Dangle Earrings with Amethyst Labradorite and Quartz
Moon On Abbeygate
Crystal Falls, MI
$60.00
Free Shipping
Which Witch is Witch?
Gnome-Work
Dennis, MA
$23.00
Free Shipping
Shadow box art - The Three
The Paper Cauldron
GA
$24.95
Trick or Treat Bags
Something Gained
MS
$17.99
Cute Skeleton Sticker - Halloween Cat, Laptop Water Bottle Wa...
Cafe de Mynx
Louisville, KY
$4.50
- 17%
Wire Crescent Moon Pendant
Glacier to Glamour
Grandville, MI
$25.00 $30.00
- 25%
Pumpkin Cat Halloween Shirt
Busy Little Body
CLINTON TOWNSHIP, MI
$13.49 $17.99
Free Shipping
Smoky Quartz Flower Crown
Judy&Madeleine
Austin, TX
$75.00
Free Shipping
True Crime Scene Handprints Beanie
Pixelknit
Idyllwild, CA
$32.00
Funny Witch Home/Desk Coaster
Personalized Country Creations
Parkersburg, WV
$8.99
Witchy, mismatched, cosplay, dark cottage core, fingerless gl...
BrennetteMarie
Sunrise, MN
$25.00
- 55%
Large Crystal Crescents
Flores et Ossa
FL
$5.00 $11.00
Fall Halloween Witch Hat Earring Studs in Purple
Brandons Baubles Shop
Denton, TX
$10.00
Black Cat wearing a Witch's Hat Halloween Plushie
Fiber Flowers And Beads
Costa Mesa, CA
$16.00
Witch Gnome
J Ro Studio
Hot Springs, SD
$35.00
Free Shipping
Carpet Inspired Witch Hat 3 inch Vinyl Stickers
Wyrd and Witchy
Greensboro, NC
$3.50
Free Shipping
Witch themed Halloween tiered tray set green cauldron
Halloween Witch Décor, Tiered Tray Set, Halloween Gift, Self ...
Sweet Tea & Butterflies
Beechgrove, TN
$49.95
Handmade one-of-a-kind woven wall hanging featuring a charm with a witch flying on a broomstick. Colors include golden yellow, orange, terra cotta, dark purple, mauve and black & white tweed woven into a bold horizontal stripe pattern. Measures 3.50 x 14.5 inches including the long 6.5 inch fringe. The hanging thread adds another 3 inches. Woven with cotton, chenille and soft silky bamboo rayon yarn. Top half only.
Free Shipping
Halloween Decor Handwoven Wall Hanging with Flying Witch Charm
Can Do Girl Design
San Diego, CA
$39.95
Free Shipping
Black Kraken Tentacle Earrings
Black or Red Tentacle Earrings
The Greene Bead
Racine, WI
$24.95
Witch Mystery Box
The Coven Club Witch Mystery Box/ customizable/ personalized/...
Crescent Auras, LLC
Vineyard, UT
$65.00
I'll Always Be A Salty Witch Halloween Sign, Coastal Fall Decor Always be a salty witch! Mermaids can be witchy to right? This fun sign has a beachy and spooky feel with it's broom riding mermaid, wearing a witches hat and bright orange starfish floating around her, and has a bit of the halloween spirit as well. Great gift idea for that mermaid lover in your life. This signs measures 5.5 x 5.5 x .75 and can stand alone on a shelf, mantel or add it to your Halloween tiered tray decor.
Free Shipping
I'll Always Be A Salty Witch Mermaid Halloween Sign
Sand & Sea Custom Signs
Boynton Beach, FL
$30.99
Free Shipping
Halloween Gnome Embroidered Iron-on Patch
The Copper Addict's Attic
Grasston, MN
$7.00
Free Spirit Journal | Witchy Gift | Unique Leatherette Cover ...
Barker Markings
CA
$27.99
Vintage Witch Nose Halloween Embroidery Applique Digital Design
Spool Embroidery
Largo, FL
$2.50
Botryoidal Stone, Titanium Quartz Polymer Clay Mother Moon Goddess Pendant
Mother Goddess Gemstone Pendant
The Greene Bead
Racine, WI
$59.95
Mystical Black Cat Halloween Purse
Simply Nifty Bags
Fuquay Varina, NC
$69.95
Hocus Pocus Coffee Helps Me Focus, Coffee Mug
Groovy Giftables
Kathleen, FL
$14.00
Butterfly Skull Earrings
Cheeky Charms
Roseville, MI
$12.00
- 25%
Witchy Cat Halloween Shirt
Busy Little Body
CLINTON TOWNSHIP, MI
$13.49 $17.99
Potion crate with witch feet sticking out
Potion Crate Halloween Decoration Halloween Gift Coworker Gift
Sweet Tea & Butterflies
Beechgrove, TN
$24.95
Free Shipping
Cloth fairy baby doll, 18 inch Red black white soft doll
Rivermist Creations
Stillwater, OK
$110.00
Free Shipping
Funny Witch Home/Desk Coaster
Personalized Country Creations
Parkersburg, WV
$8.99
Free Shipping
Halloween Haunted Doll Upcycled Home Decor - Emerald
Susan's Sweet Finds
Gilbert, AZ
$125.00
Free Shipping
Gothel 6.5oz Candle, Apple Patchouli Woods
Serpent & Flame Candle Co
Alsip, IL
$15.99
Celestial Moon Goddess Hair Barrette, Polymer Clay Lunar Witc...
Paula McNulty Designs
Manhasset, NY
$36.00
Don't Be A Crabby Witch Halloween Sign No one likes a crabby witch! This fun sign has a coastal feel with it's crabby graphic as well as the traditional Halloween spirit! A bright orange pumpkin is all about the fall, and how cute is that bat lurking in the background! This signs measures 5.5 x 5.5 x .75 and can stand alone on a shelf, mantel or add it to your Halloween tiered tray decor.
Free Shipping
Don't Be A Crabby Witch Halloween Sign
Sand & Sea Custom Signs
Boynton Beach, FL
$30.99
Free Shipping
Small backpack Bat print canvas
Lara Howe Designs
Springfield, OR
$48.00
- 10%
Crescent Moon Over Amethyst Pendant
Glacier to Glamour
Grandville, MI
$45.00 $50.00
Free Shipping
Silver Witch Small Coffin Wallet
Morrow & Meowley
PHILADELPHIA, PA
$49.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Oya earrings, Yansa paperclip stainless steel chain with stai...
ModernOrisha
NJ
$28.00
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Witch Altar, miniature framed tripod decorative shrine, mini...
ModernOrisha
NJ
$28.00
Free Shipping
Old Salem Broom Company Halloween Sign
GobbyBritDesigns
San Bernardino, CA
$14.95
Free Shipping
Celestial Crystal Handbag
Sew That Liz
Columbus, IN
$95.00
Free Shipping
Halloween skull dangle earrings, with black and orange crystals.
Halloween Skull Dangle Earrings
Moon On Abbeygate
Crystal Falls, MI
$30.00
Magic is Brewing Planner Stickers - Witch Stickers - Hallowee...
Strawberry Blondie Art
VISTA, CA
$3.50
Vintage Halloween Witch Embroidery Applique Digital Design
Spool Embroidery
Largo, FL
$2.50
I smell Children Shirt, Black Candle Shirt, Witches Shirt
Genevieve By Mom
Chantilly, VA
$20.00
Free Shipping
metaphysical earrings, Divination earrings, double sided, pal...
ModernOrisha
NJ
$22.00
Free Shipping
Crochet Witch Hat: Skye
Black Water Crafts
Southaven, MS
$75.00
Black Cat Coffee Co ceramic engraved mug
Black Cat Coffee Company Halloween Mug
GobbyBritDesigns
San Bernardino, CA
$15.95
Free Shipping
Mermaid Book Witch, fall, Halloween, vintage, librarian, reu...
Treecycled
Waterford, NY
$57.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Funny Apron Gift, Rather Be Roasting Heretics, Minister, Past...
A Gift To Treasure
Clinton, MO
$38.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Halloween Apron, Witch Costume, Orange Black, Custom Birthday...
A Gift To Treasure
Clinton, MO
$32.95
Free Shipping
Rose Quartz crystal gold brass crescent moon celestial witchy...
Love Laurel Rae
Buckeye, AZ
$40.00
Witchy Pumpkin Earrings
Goose Girl
King George, VA
$14.95
Witchy Woman Enamel Camp Mug
Life in Color Design
CA
$16.99
Crow Skull Earrings
Cheeky Charms
Roseville, MI
$12.00
Free Shipping
Witch's Brew Splatter Paint Crewneck Sweatshirt
Homespun Hacks Creations LLC
Allendale, MI
$32.00
Free Shipping
Wicked Witch Halloween Magnet, Stained Wood "Wicked" Witch Ha...
WeeCraftyCreations
Granite Falls, WA
$8.99
Halloween cauldron and book of spells earrings
Baubles and Beasties
WAKITA, OK
$7.49
Salem Witch Book Club PNG-Halloween Sublimation Digital Desig...
She Shed Craft Store
FL
$1.97