Search...
Selected StatesShop Local0Everywhere
Shop Local Makers

A

C

D

F

G

H

I

K

L

M

N

O

P

R

S

T

U

V

W

Menu
All Things Witchy Maker Challenge Collection
All Things Witchy Maker Challenge Collection


Winner - Paula McNulty Designs
Finalist - Northern Owl Creations


Top Submissions

Free Shipping
The Lydia, Smoky Quartz Crystal Crown
Judy&Madeleine
Austin, TX
$75.00
Free Shipping
2"x6" Gold Orange Coffin Bookmark with Tassel - Halloween Car...
Cafe de Mynx
Louisville, KY
$3.99
Halloween purse with witches, black cats and ravens
Simply Nifty Bags
Fuquay Varina, NC
$49.95

More to Consider

Free Shipping
Rainbow Moonstone 14k Gold Filled Ring • Faceted Crescent Moo...
Jackrabbit Crystals
Roseville, CA
$30.00
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
BAT Small Coffin Wallet
Morrow & Meowley
PHILADELPHIA, PA
$49.95
Free Shipping
Goddess Altar
Crescent Auras, LLC
Vineyard, UT
$55.00
Activated charcoal soap scented with blend of patchouli, sand...
ikkilikki
Wilmington, NC
$8.95
Black leather masquerade mask for unisex adult. Wicked witch,...
Beadmask
Olympia, WA
$54.00
Free Shipping
Colorful Witch Brooms for Adults, Teens, Tweens and Child, Un...
Meckley Brooms
Lopez, PA
$80.00
Free Shipping
Real Leather Witch Cauldron Pouch, 5' x 7" Tarot Pouch, Orac...
Triple Goddess Craft
Clayton, NC
$13.00
Free Shipping
Necklace set | Elemental magic, Tektite pendants, collar styl...
Dark Poet Designs | Unique Bead Jewelry
Los Ranchos, NM
$179.00
Free Shipping
Black witch cat for Halloween decor
Swamp Rabbit Merchant
Laurens, SC
$40.00
Halloween Bracelet Stack for WomenMen-Kids
Starfish by Kristan
Delray Beach, FL
$12.95
- 20%
Blood and Bone Scarlet Pearl Necklace
The Mystic Victorian
Aubrey, TX
$72.00 $90.00
Free Shipping
Custom cuddle dragon with hoodie
Rivermist Creations
Perkins, OK
$138.00
Free Shipping
Black poop bag holder with RIP Coffin shape. Personalization ...
A Fur Baby Favorite
CENTRE, AL
$19.95
Witchy Oops
Witchy Oops
Country Treasures
Monticello, KY
$7.95
Illustrated mini journals - Teacup Garden (set of 3)
The Paper Cauldron
Darien, GA
$34.95
Witch Kitty Plush Animal Set
Creations by Orange
Goodyear, AZ
$30.00
Amethyst Lamp
Hillside Designs AZ
Phoenix, AZ
$250.00
Free Shipping
Witch bells door hanger
All The Things
Pasadena, MD
$12.00
Free Shipping
Dear Salem You Missed One Witch Journal Unique Leatherette Co...
Barker Markings
CA
$27.99
Free Shipping
Halloween Paint and Play Set
Northern Owl Creations
Lehi, UT
$38.00
Free Shipping
Hauntingly Beautiful Halloween Candy Corn Beaded Charm Necklace
Starfish by Kristan
Delray Beach, FL
$19.95
Gemstone dangle hoop earrings, with amethyst slices, yellow quartz, and labradorite.
Free Shipping
Gemstone Dangle Earrings with Amethyst Labradorite and Quartz
Moon On Abbeygate
Crystal Falls, MI
$65.00
Free Shipping
Shadow box art - The Three
The Paper Cauldron
Darien, GA
$39.95
Cute Skeleton Sticker - Halloween Cat, Laptop Water Bottle Wa...
Cafe de Mynx
Louisville, KY
$4.50
Pumpkin Cat Halloween Shirt
Busy Little Body
CLINTON TOWNSHIP, MI
$17.99
Free Shipping
Smoky Quartz Flower Crown
Judy&Madeleine
Austin, TX
$75.00
Free Shipping
Witchy, mismatched, cosplay, dark cottage core, fingerless gl...
BrennetteMarie
Sunrise, MN
$25.00
- 55%
Large Crystal Crescents
Flores et Ossa
FL
$5.00 $11.00
Black Cat wearing a Witch's Hat Halloween Plushie
Fiber Flowers And Beads
Costa Mesa, CA
$16.00
Witch Gnome
J Ro Studio
Hot Springs, SD
$35.00
Free Shipping
Carpet Inspired Witch Hat 3 inch Vinyl Stickers
Wyrd and Witchy
Greensboro, NC
$3.50
Free Shipping
Witch themed Halloween tiered tray set green cauldron
Halloween Witch Décor, Tiered Tray Set, Halloween Gift, Self ...
Sweet Tea & Butterflies
Beechgrove, TN
$49.95
Black Kraken Tentacle Earrings
Black or Red Tentacle Earrings
The Greene Bead
Racine, WI
$24.95
Witch Mystery Box
The Coven Club Witch Mystery Box/ customizable/ personalized/...
Crescent Auras, LLC
Vineyard, UT
$65.00
I'll Always Be A Salty Witch Halloween Sign, Coastal Fall Decor Always be a salty witch! Mermaids can be witchy to right? This fun sign has a beachy and spooky feel with it's broom riding mermaid, wearing a witches hat and bright orange starfish floating around her, and has a bit of the halloween spirit as well. Great gift idea for that mermaid lover in your life. This signs measures 5.5 x 5.5 x .75 and can stand alone on a shelf, mantel or add it to your Halloween tiered tray decor.
Free Shipping
I'll Always Be A Salty Witch Mermaid Halloween Sign
Sand & Sea Custom Signs
Boynton Beach, FL
$30.99
Free Shipping
Free Spirit Journal | Witchy Gift | Unique Leatherette Cover ...
Barker Markings
CA
$27.99
Vintage Witch Nose Halloween Embroidery Applique Digital Design
Spool Embroidery
Largo, FL
$2.50
Botryoidal Stone, Titanium Quartz Polymer Clay Mother Moon Goddess Pendant
Mother Goddess Gemstone Pendant
The Greene Bead
Racine, WI
$59.95
Butterfly Skull Earrings
Cheeky Charms
Roseville, MI
$15.00
- 10%
Witchy Cat Halloween Shirt
Busy Little Body
CLINTON TOWNSHIP, MI
$17.99 $19.95
Potion crate with witch feet sticking out
Potion Crate Halloween Decoration Halloween Gift Coworker Gift
Sweet Tea & Butterflies
Beechgrove, TN
$24.95
Celestial Moon Goddess Hair Barrette, Polymer Clay Lunar Witc...
Paula McNulty Designs
New Hyde Park, NY
$36.00
Don't Be A Crabby Witch Halloween Sign No one likes a crabby witch! This fun sign has a coastal feel with it's crabby graphic as well as the traditional Halloween spirit! A bright orange pumpkin is all about the fall, and how cute is that bat lurking in the background! This signs measures 5.5 x 5.5 x .75 and can stand alone on a shelf, mantel or add it to your Halloween tiered tray decor.
Free Shipping
Don't Be A Crabby Witch Halloween Sign
Sand & Sea Custom Signs
Boynton Beach, FL
$30.99
Free Shipping
- 10%
Crescent Moon Over Amethyst Pendant
Glacier to Glamour
Grandville, MI
$45.00 $50.00
Old Salem Broom Company Halloween Sign
GobbyBritDesigns
San Bernardino, CA
$14.95
Free Shipping
- 24%
Celestial Crystal Handbag
Sew That Liz
Columbus, IN
$81.43 $107.15
Free Shipping
Halloween skull dangle earrings, with black and orange crystals.
Free Shipping
Halloween Skull Dangle Earrings
Moon On Abbeygate
Crystal Falls, MI
$32.00
Free Shipping
Magic is Brewing Planner Stickers - Witch Stickers - Hallowee...
Strawberry Blondie Art
VISTA, CA
$3.50
Vintage Halloween Witch Embroidery Applique Digital Design
Spool Embroidery
Largo, FL
$2.50
I smell Children Shirt, Black Candle Shirt, Witches Shirt
Genevieve By Mom
Chantilly, VA
$20.00
- 20%
Crochet Witch Hat: Skye
Black Water Crafts
Southaven, MS
$60.00 $75.00
Black Cat Coffee Co ceramic engraved mug
Black Cat Coffee Company Halloween Mug
GobbyBritDesigns
San Bernardino, CA
$15.95
Free Shipping
Mermaid Book Witch, fall, Halloween, vintage, librarian, reu...
Treecycled
Waterford, NY
$57.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Funny Apron Gift, Rather Be Roasting Heretics, Minister, Past...
A Gift To Treasure
Clinton, MO
$38.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Halloween Apron, Witch Costume, Orange Black, Custom Birthday...
A Gift To Treasure
Clinton, MO
$32.95
Free Shipping
Crow Skull Earrings
Cheeky Charms
Roseville, MI
$15.00
Witch's Brew Splatter Paint Crewneck Sweatshirt
Homespun Hacks Creations LLC
Allendale, MI
$32.00
Wicked Witch Halloween Magnet, Stained Wood "Wicked" Witch Ha...
WeeCraftyCreations
Granite Falls, WA
$8.99
Halloween cauldron and book of spells earrings
Baubles and Beasties
WAKITA, OK
$7.49
Home
Menu
Account
Cart