Search...
Selected StatesShop Local0Everywhere
Shop Local Makers

A

C

D

F

G

H

I

K

L

M

N

O

P

R

S

T

U

V

W

Menu

Handmade Bay Gift Shop

Welcome to Handmade Bay Gift Shop, Where Every Creation Tells a Story!
Georgetown, New York
Meet the Maker
5.0
Contact Maker
Welcome to Handmade Bay Gift Shop, Where Every Creation Tells a Story! New Items coming this week!!!
Contact Maker


Search this Shop Search this Shop

Shop Categories Shop Categories

Product Filters Product Filters

Price Filter

$  –  $

  • ‎$3.95
  • ‎$124.95
Reset

Featured Products

Free Shipping
What the Fucculent Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$4.95
Free Shipping
Box of Happy Plants
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$21.95
Free Shipping
Welcome to My Garden Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$4.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Hey Birdie Domino Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Traveling Heart Domino Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Rabbit Masquerade Upcycled Domino Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Enjoy Good Times Wall Art
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.99
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Live for Today Wall Art Shadow Box
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.99
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Thank you with Flowers Wall Art Shadow Box
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.99
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Keychain Summer Sweets
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Keychain Say Cheese
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Candy Shaker Keychain
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Sunflower Upcycled Domino Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Mushrooms Upcycled Domino Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Rabbit's at Play Upcycled Domino Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Magentic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Habit Tracker Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping

ProductsProducts found: 214

Sort by Popularity
96 Products Per Page
Filters & Sorting
Free Shipping
Tarot Cards Die Cut Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Mushroom Die Cut Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Steampunk Inspired Die Cut Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Nursery Wall Art - Always Reach for the Stars
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
- 12%
Bible Story Die Cut Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95 $16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Earth, Moon, and Stars Die Cut Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Garden Embellishment Die Cut Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Mixed Media Journal - Fuzzy Duckling
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$44.95
Free Shipping
Handmade Valentine 70's inspired Journal
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$39.95
Free Shipping
Baby Keepsake Tag - To the Moon and Back
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Baby Milestone Keepsake Album (blue)
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$39.95
Free Shipping
New Beginnings Mixed Media Journal
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$34.95
Free Shipping
Mixed Media Journal Summer Vibes
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$34.95
Free Shipping
Jesus and the Children Die Cut Pack - junk journals/gifts/pap...
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Unicorn Mixed Media Journal
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$39.95
Nursery Wall Art - Never Stop Dreaming Little One
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Birthday Bash Pocket Notepad
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Be Happy Inspired Shadow Box Wall Decor
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.99
Nursery Wall Art - Hello World!
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Thank you for Being A Friend
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Picture Frame - Made with Love Dragonflies
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Picture Frame - Off To Grandmas's
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Find a Way, Not an Excuse' Window Cling
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$8.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Be Happy Snarky Window Cling Suncatcher
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$8.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Be Yourself Window Cling
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$8.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Everything You Imagine Window Cling
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$8.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Keychain Box Pouch - Honeybees
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Lemons and Shine Keychain Pouch
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Keychain Lip Balm Holders
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Farmhouse Themed Keychain Pouch
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Farmhouse Sticker Surprise Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Yoga Cat Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Candy Shaker Keychain
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Custom Photo Stickers
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$4.95
Free Shipping
Deer Hunting Keychain
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Sweet Slice Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Seasonal Love Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Shopping Spree Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Happy Times Notepad and Keychain Gift Set (lefty friendly)
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Sewing Stickers
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$7.00
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Hiking Life Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Box of Happy Plants
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$21.95
Free Shipping
Outdoorsman Keychain
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Harvest Hoot Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Dream Big Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Explorer Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Winged Harmony Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Legends Domino Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
80's Pen Pal Stationery Set
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$29.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Unicorn Spirit Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Giraffe Stickers
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$6.95
Free Shipping
Vintage Fashion 3D Art
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$29.95
Free Shipping
I Love Sushi Stickers
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$6.95
Free Shipping
Winter Adventures With Bestie Shadow Art
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.99
Free Shipping
Mixed Media Astrology Themed Journal
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Notebook and Keychain Set - Good Vibes (lefty friendly)
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Small Business Stickers
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$10.50
Free Shipping
Vintage Friends Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Besties Slaying in Style and Sass Wall Art
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.99
Free Shipping
Coffee and Crime Shows Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Fueled By Caffeine and Crime Shows Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Koi Themed Pen Pal Stationery Kit
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$29.95
Free Shipping
Camping Keychain
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Baby Bear Stickers
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$6.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Armchair Detective Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Pen Pal Stationery Kit -Full Bloom
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$29.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Haunt People Ghost Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Outdoorsman Keychain
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$14.95
Free Shipping
Good Vibes Sticker Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Don't Mess With a Woman Who Knows How To Stage a Crime Scene ...
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Kinda Classy, Kinda Hood Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Sunshine Mixed with a Little Hurricane Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$4.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Eyes Rolled Outloud Snarky Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Dancing Queen Shadow Box
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Dog Hair is My Glitter Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
I can't make everyone happy, I'm not a Taco Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Roadtrip Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
I Run on Caffeine, Chaos, and Cuss Words Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$4.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Cactus Friends Sticker Sheet
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$6.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Stressed, Blessed, and True Crime Obsessed
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Besties Day Out Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Beach Bliss 3D Shadow Box
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$19.95
Free Shipping
Magnetic Bookmark
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$9.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Springtime Symphony Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Sleighin' or Slayin' Christmas Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
January Recipe Card Set
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$12.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Classic Alice Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Kiss My Grits Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
July Recipe Card Set
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$12.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
How May I Offend You Today Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Aloha Upcycled Pendant
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$24.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
Self Care Sticker Pack
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$16.95
Free Shipping
Free Shipping
I'd Rather Be Watching Crime Shows Sticker
Handmade Bay Gift Shop
NY
$3.95
Free Shipping
 Prev
1 2 3
Next 
Home
Menu
Account
Cart